Choosing between Fisheye and Bitbucket to integrate with Crucible and Jira

[Vladimir Litvinenko]

Hello. Please give advice on selecting products from this list: Crucible, Fisheye, Bitbucket

Our company uses Jira. The source code will be stored in the Git repository and we will conduct a code review in Crucible.

In the development process, we would like to use the following functionality:

1) The developer, when solving a task, makes several commits to the git repository. We want to see a link to the list of these commits in the Jira task as shown in the following screenshot: https://ds6br8f5qp1u2.cloudfront.net/blog/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/integrate-JIRA-GitHub-for-web-development.png?x88475

2) After clicking on the link  “commits” we want to be able to "Create a code review for all commits" as shown in the following screenshot https://confluence.atlassian.com/fisheye/files/298976858/456654877/2/1444173699657/FU-changesets.png  (see upper right corner of screenshot)

3) After creating the code review  for the task as a whole, we want to see a link to created Code Review in the Development section of  Jira task next to the links that leads to commits. Almost as shown in the following screenshot, but instead of “pull request” there should be a “code review”.

https://marketplace-cdn.atlassian.com/files/images/com.atlassian.jira.plugins.jira-bitbucket-connector-plugin/86ff1a21-44fb-4227-aa4f-44c77aec2c97.png

4) We don't want to see links to commits and reviews simply in the “links” section of the task. We want to see them on the right side of the task window in Jira in the “Development” section.

5) In the Crucible review, created for several commits within one task, we want to see a slider that allows us to view the history of code changes related to the task:  https://i.ytimg.com/vi/UFNPgfQFJHk/maxresdefault.jpg  (see the red slider on the screenshot)

6) If the file was changed after creating the review, we need the "File outdated" link, which allows adding a new version of the file in the review as shown in the following screenshot: https://confluence.atlassian.com/crucible/files/298977444/299140749/1/1287474611258/Crucible-2.3_Review-File-Outdated.png

It is known that Fisheye allows to host git repositories. Also we have information that the functionality of Crucible will be definitely limited without Fisheye, even with Bitbucket. For example without Fisheye there will be no “File outdated” link. Therefore, it seems that we can apply the combination Crucible + Fisheye and do not use Bitbucket.

But we still need integration with Jira :   links to commits and reviews in Development section of task, ability to create review for all commits within one task and see reviews tatus next to the “review” link in Jira.

Is it enough for us to use Crucible and Fisheye in order to meet the above requirements?

Or is it enough for us to use Crucible and Bitbucket?

[Angélica Luz]

Hi Vladimir,

I've checked that you opened a ticket with our Product Advocates related to this same questions and all your questions were answered.
If you need any additional information, please let us know.

Regards,
Angélica