are the validator check for comment is a behaviour in jira

[Karim Belhadj]

Hello team

I read that  question ; 

Witch workflow configuration is redundant with jira's default behaviour .

The answer was :  A validator that cheks for a comment .

Sincerly , i do not understand this , can someone help me to understand and where can i see it in a test instance ?

Regards

[Nic Brough -Adaptavist-]

I am afraid I do not understand the question - could you give us more context?  Where did you read this question?  If it is one of the exam questions, what were the other options? 

I ask because the answer you've been given there really sounds wrong - it would only be the right answer if the other 3 (or more) options were inarguably wrong.

[Karim Belhadj]

@Nic Brough -Adaptavist-  it's not examen question :  

the question is 

Witch workflow configuration is redundant with jira's default behaviour ?

.A post function that assigns to the current user

.A validator that cheks for a comment .

.adding the assignee field to a transition screen

.a commit created trigger 

.setting the jira.issue.editable property to false 

.a condition for the transition issues permission

answer : B 

can you understand something , for me it's weird .

Regards

[Nic Brough -Adaptavist-]

I wonder where you're getting that question from, because

1. It's not brilliantly written (several of the possible answers are wrong for more than one reason, making them easier to rule out for people who are certain, but seeding doubts for the rest of us)
2. The answer they've given you is utterly wrong.

The right answer is the last one, the condition. 

[Karim Belhadj]

@Nic Brough -Adaptavist-  is the atlassian exam question are brillantly written and not like this ? Im preparing to pass the exam .

Regards 

[Nic Brough -Adaptavist-]

I hope they are - I helped write a load of them over 3 years ago, and we were trained to write questions that were clear and understandable, with selections that were inarguably right or wrong.  There was a rigourous peer-review and atlassian-review process and extensive beta testing weeding out and improving or discarding poor questions.

Poor questions are caused by unclear language, arguable answer keys, and introducing relativity - a bad question is "what is the best way to ..." because you can't often select the right answer without knowing the exact circumstances, which is not possible in a couple of sentences.

However, since then, other people have been writing questions to add to the pool and it feels like they did not do the training we got (There were arguable "what is the best..." questions in the badges I've taken, which were terrible questions).  Also, many people complained that the language was often complex, and Atlassian tried to get it simplified, and it looks like that process, rather than improving the questions, made them wrong or arguable.

[Rahul Jodavula]

@Karim Belhadj , Nic is right the answer is the last one .

Yes its an atlassian questin which i faced for ACP - 100 .  But the answer provided by many sites is wrong . The correct answer is last option