Mosiac and Float tools verses Jira/Advanced Roadmaps

[Nick Vitovitch]

Does anyone have experience with Mosaic and/or Float and how do these compare with Jira/Advanced Roadmaps?

I have a user that is proposing to use these tools for the following:

We are trying to have a simple tool which can do resource management (we have about 20 team members on our team performing multiple audits/projects at any time) so Internal Audit Leadership can have a view into what everyone is working on.  Currently doing in Excel is extremely cumbersome and time consuming.

 Further, we would like the tool to also do time tracking for all individuals as well. 

I would think this would be a standard project with a dashboard and using Advanced Roadmaps for the resource management. I have not experience with Mosaic or Float so do not understand what they provide that Jira/Advanced Roadmaps does not.