Can Security Levels work to limit visibility of issues in the Service Desk portal?

[ex.Geir Sigurður Jónsson]

I have a Service Desk portal - with issues separated as expected using Organizations.  I also have customers that access the same issues through JIRA (not the service portal), using Security Levels to limit their issue access.

My question is, is the Atlassian plan to use Security Levels somehow with the Service Portal or should the Security Level and Organization be thought of as completely separate security models (one for JIRA and the other for SD)?  

I am currently taking advantage of the feature (bug?) ..  that removing "Service Desk Customer - Portal Access" from a Security Level, removes access for all portal users, except those that have access to the Security Level.   This could both be considered as a feature and a bug ... :)

[Andy Heinzer · Accepted solution]

Think of them as completely separate security models, because they are.   I can understand why you might consider these to be similar, they do provide similar functions within JIRA.    But the documentation on Customizing JIRA Service Desk permissions explains what this Service Desk security scheme does.  From Customizing Jira Service Desk permissions:

In addition, if the service desk project uses an issue security scheme, make sure that it is configured so that service desk users can view issues. Otherwise, customers might be able to create issues but not view them after they've been created. See Configuring issue-level security. 

By default, no projects in JIRA automatically use an issue level security scheme.   Not even Service Desk projects.   But Service Desk projects do have a way to separate access to issues for Service Desk customer only users.  These users only have access to the customer portal, which in turn is only showing issues that they are the reporter, or where they have been added as a requested participant, or possibly issues that have been shared with their organization.

Yes I believe you could further restrict user access to specific issues in the customer portal with an issue level security scheme.  But I'd recommend being careful with doing so.   I could foresee scenarios where customer portal only users might be able to create issues, but then never see them because they lack the security level assigned to the issue, or possibly they could be prevented from creating issues altogether.

[Peter Friberg]

I have an issue security scheme applied to a service desk project. Dependent on which options the user select at Create, a certain security level will be set in a post function so that only certain agents will be able to see the ticket. Besides, the security level also gives access issue to "Service Desk Customer - Portal Access"

A ticket is created with the correct security level, and the customer user is provided a direct link to the issue in the portal, and the user has access to the ticket. The "Requests" count at the top right increases with one. However, when viewing the requests list, the new ticket is not listed. The same behavior also applies to request participant. 
Email notification is also sent to the customer user.

Assuming that it is a bug that the ticket is not listed.

Service Desk version is 3.16.1

[maguialahmar]

Hi Peter, 

i m applying the same solution but i can see all requests. so i dont think it is a bug... or maybe it was a bug :) 

[Игорь Кувшинников]

@maguialahmar 
Hi!
Does your solution work with organizations?
I mean can members share their requests with other members of their organization?

[Sylvain Leduc]

Hello @Peter Friberg 

4 years later, I do have the same bug with JSM 4.20.10.

It only affects Agents raising a JSM ticket on the same JSM project they have agent permissions.

They can create it, can access it through the customer portal /servicedesk/41/ISSUE-123 but not listed in their own portal.

Any news from Atlassian about it, a link to a public ticket maybe ?

Thanks.